said about the doctrine of the immortality of the soul, ..

They did not answer the question which was, "Why is it necessary that God offer eternal life to every soul?" They simply restated their beliefs. In the second and third sentences of their answer they claim:

Plato's Phaedo: The Soul's Immortality - Sample Essays

Even if there is life after death, Cebes suggests, the soul may not be truly immortal.

Immortality | Immortality | Soul

It is rational to think that the soul, that part of our being that cannot be reduced to matter, will live forward after our body has died.

immortality of the soul | Immortal Us, Our Memories …

The very real rebels in fight for a very real cause in a very real world, yet the conception of fantasy outlined above remains central to their enterprise. Although the doctor urges Mercedes' brother to cross the border with his men and flee Franco's regime rather than resisting it, the rebels reject a literal "escape" and instead adhere to their imagined ideals. The doctor's eventual heroic act of disobedience to Vidal exemplifies this alternative definition of "escape" in fantasy, an escape from the imposed restrictions of a tyrannous reality. Del Toro's desire to reconfigure the concepts of escape and escapism also makes itself evident in the prologue of the film, in which the narrator explains that the princess from the Underground Realm to enter the real world. This reversal, in which an individual escapes into rather than from reality, foreshadows the way in which del Toro will call into question the standard dismissal of fantasy as escapist. In fact, the character that is most dismissive of Ofelia's fairy tales, her mother, is also the character who offers the least resistance to Captain Vidal's oppression, performing the ultimate act of submission in marrying him. When Ofelia asks her second mother figure, Mercedes, if she believes in fairies, Mercedes replies in the negative, yet qualifies her disbelief: "But when I was a little girl, I did. I believed in a lot of things I don't believe anymore." In these words, Mercedes appears to be claiming that she has lost her beliefs or her faith, but her courageous actions bear witness to what she very much continues to believe in: the rightness of the cause and her contributions to it. In a way, the rebels' great "fantasy" of regaining their country and their freedom, and their belief in that struggle, remains the most inspiring ideal in the film, regardless of the fate of their souls. For, as awful as it seems, we must imagine Mercedes and all her companions as very likely dying for their beliefs, perhaps only a month or two after the events of the film. Nevertheless, we should view their deaths in the service of that ideal as no less golden than Ofelia's return to the Underground Realm, and thus their own collective end only represents a tragedy if we refuse to share their vision.

Notice how the detail of the parable is completely irreconcilable with commonly held views of immortal souls in heaven and hell.


According to the so-called "Christian" religions the real is dwelling within the temporal body. The body is seen as a temporary suit of clothes. The real person dwells within that temporary suit of clothes; and at the time of death, the now useless "suit of clothes" (the body) is discarded, buried in the ground or cremated, while the real person wafts away either to heaven or to ever-burning hell fire! (In the Catholic tradition, there are allegedly various intermediary stages called "purgatory. ")

How can you , one way or the other?

What is your ultimate authority for determining the truth on any subject which has to do with life and death, judgment, and the hereafter?

For the purposes of this article, the absolute, final and divine is theBible, the inspired, written Word of God, as it appears in its earliest manuscripts, and in its original languages!

If your "authority" for your beliefs is myth, superstition, fables, stories of alleged death-bed visions or conversations with "departed souls"; if your "authority" is mysticism, oriental religions, heathen superstitions or esoterica, then you should read no further-for this article accepts as the only and authority on the subject of the so-called "immortality of the soul" , the written Word of God!

WHY, then, if so many hundreds of millions of human beings in so many nations are absolutely convinced they possess an immortal soul are the words "immortal soul" FOUND NOWHERE in Scripture?

Religion and Spirituality: On the Immortality of the Soul

We could just as well speak about the substantial soul of a ship which leaves harbour, loosing today a plank, which is replaced by another one of the same shape and size, loosing then another piece, which is also replaced and so forth, until the same ship comes back with the same shape and the same seaworthy features and everybody recognizes it as the same one.”

The “Immortality ” of the Soul ..

So Unamunomakes a sophistic objection as follows: “How can an unaware reason conclude that our soul is a substance (which subsists, or stays) from the fact that our consciousness of identity persists during the changes of our body?

10.2 ) THE IMMORTALITY OF THE SOUL. | Aware of The …

But in that case, the existence of our mortal bodies cannot be essential to the existence of our souls—before birth or after death—and we are therefore immortal.